The Energy Wise Attic Door Insulation Cover has an insulation value of R-15.5, the highest for zippered insulators (although not by much). A popular and highly reviewed item on Amazon, this product features a reflective foil covering and a fail-safe zipper for easy access.
One Amazon reviewer praised the design, writing: “Having two zippers that meet rather than one that goes from one full side to the other is also super convenient.”
The zipper-type Panady Attic Stairs Insulation Cover comes with a 15.4 R-value. It features Class A fire resistance as well as a foil cover that reflects 97% of radiant heat. That’s important for keeping the house cool on hot days.
Amazon reviewers gave it 4.7 stars out of five. Several liked its easy installation, with one writing it took less than five minutes with a staple gun.
Designed to be used on hatch and folding attic ladders, this insulation cover is great for both hot and cold temperatures. It comes with everything you need to install it (including adhesive required for assembly) and boasts an R-value of 38, making it a super thermally resistant option.
Complete with a 2o-year warranty, this is one of the pricier options we found. However, it’s definitely worth it, especially if you live in an older space that gets especially drafty or warm.
Basic Attic Stairway Insulation Cover
The Duck Brand Plastic Attic Stairway Cover doesn’t have an R-rating and doesn’t insulate as well as some other products. It does provide some insulation, though. And it works great for anyone who wants to prevent attic insulation and other debris from blowing downstairs.
This is a tent-style cover similar to the Owens Corning product, but it weighs about five pounds less and offers more clearance. Setup is easy: Take it out of the box, unfold it and set it in place.
If you were to DIY your stairwell cover, you’d probably come up with something similar to the Battic Attic Stair Cover. It’s basically a box that fits over the stairwell. You can pack it with insulation to get an R-50 value.
This product costs twice as much as other stair covers, and you may have to purchase extra insulation. It comes with weatherstripping to make a seal against the door frame. It’s what you need if your local building code requires the cover to have the same R-value as the rest of the attic.
A true DIY solution, insulation rolls are another way you can keep your attic sealed off. They may not be as effective as insulation covers with high R-values, but this industrial-strength material is said to block 95% of radiant heat gain and loss. It’s also non-toxic, non-carcinogenic and fiber-free.
The roll comes with 1,000 square feet of material that you can staple to the underside of attic roof rafters. It’s also safe to place on any attic walls.
Bonus: It has a 4.7-star rating from more than 600 Amazon shoppers who pledge for its functionality.